Mediation Preparation Checklist

A mediation preparation checklist covering process, risk analysis, negotiation strategy, and closing—for counsel and parties preparing for mediation.

Download the PDF

Not every item applies to every case. Work through what fits the matter in front of you.

1. The Mediation Process

  • Mediation is a search for a mutually acceptable resolution that matches the risk of continued litigation. No one determines who is the prevailing party; it is designed to avoid the risk of loss.
  • Less formal than the rest of litigation—the focus is productive conversation over legal argument.
  • The mediator is neutral and cannot impose an outcome. Nothing is settled unless the parties agree.
  • Private caucus discussions with the mediator are candid and can be confidential if flagged.
  • A negotiated settlement allows terms a court cannot order—payment structures, non-monetary relief, confidentiality, releases, and future arrangements—plus flexibility and risk management.
  • Explain the shape of the day: caucusing, shuttle negotiation, down time. Expect and prepare for possible multiple impasses that will need to be worked through.
  • Explain that early offers are rarely the last, and that waiting between mediator visits is normal.
  • Review applicable confidentiality and privilege rules. Confidentiality of mediations is governed by evidence rules and mediation statutes, if any. Confidentiality can be increased by agreement under a Mediation Agreement. Some cases involving public entities may not be subject to contractual confidentiality.

2. The Mediator’s Role

  • Transformative: empowers parties, improves communication, rebuilds relationships.
  • Facilitative: guides discussion, asks questions, clarifies issues neutrally.
  • Evaluative: assesses the case, suggests settlement options, takes a more directive approach.
  • Mediators often mix approaches. Consider what the client and the case need.
  • Consider and talk to the client about the mediator discussing the risk profile of their case.

3. Participants, Authority, and Approvals

  • Identify key participants: parties, insurers, personal attorneys, CPAs, or trusted advisors.
  • Confirm the individual with actual settlement authority will attend or be reachable all day.
  • Understand that who is and how they are participating is disclosed to all parties; that is not a confidential communication.
  • Identify any approval that makes a settlement conditional—excess carriers, court approval, guardians, fiduciaries, lenders, spouses, or partners.
  • Identify lienholders and any party with a right to subrogation. Obtain current financial information for total balance (payoff) and reinstatement, if relevant.
  • Identify contractual constraints: consent-to-settle clauses, indemnity obligations, joint defense agreements.
  • Confirm the client’s authority is documented—resolutions, powers of attorney, fiduciary authority.

A settlement that requires a signature from someone not participating is not a settlement. Identify required approvals in advance.

4. Identifying Interests, BATNA, and WATNA

  • Position = what a party demands (e.g., “I want the house”).
  • Interest = the underlying need (e.g., financial security, avoiding disruption).
  • List and rank the party’s interests. Examples: money, certainty, speed, sustaining an ongoing relationship, optics, reputation, confidentiality, avoiding precedent, acknowledgment, and relief from anxiety and stress.
  • Do the same for the other side. Identify at least one thing you can offer that they would value.
  • BATNA: best likely legal outcome, minus remaining fees, costs, and risk. Consider time, cost, stress, and collectability.
  • WATNA: worst likely legal outcome, including fee awards, interest, and other losses (distraction from primary business).
  • Assess realistically: does the best legal outcome satisfy the client’s highest-ranked interests? Does a negotiated agreement satisfy them better?
  • Develop a possible settlement range and do not establish “bottom lines.”

5. Risk and Case Analysis

  • Strengths and weaknesses of the legal claims and the fact disputes, element by element.
  • Credibility of key witnesses, including the client, as a factfinder will see them.
  • Evidentiary risk; venue, judge, and comparable outcomes; appellate exposure.
  • Probability breakdown: multiply the hurdles—Example: 50% liability × 50% damages = 25% success rate. A case may feel worth the risk to litigate but examine in depth.
  • Build a damages range—low, likely, high—with offsets, interest, and fee-shifting exposure.
  • If seeking a monetary judgment, consider collection risks: assets, policy limits and erosion, solvency, enforcement burden.
  • Calculate the client’s net recovery after fees, costs, liens, and taxes.
  • Experienced parties: If a party such as a large entity or insurance company has significant experience or results from similar cases, focus on case-specific nuance and comparables and examine whether this is truly similar or an outlier.
  • Parties new to litigation: use plain language, concrete examples, and written summaries.

6. Common Negotiation Biases

  • Fixed-pie bias — assuming a purely zero-sum game.
  • Vividness bias — over-focusing on one term, fact, or document.
  • Escalation of commitment — refusing to shift strategies despite mounting losses.
  • Framing effect — risk averse in gains, risk seeking to avoid losses.
  • Anchoring — over-adjusting to the first number on the table.
  • Reactive devaluation — discounting a proposal because of who made it.
  • Confirmation Bias/Overconfidence — a known bias and lens that evaluates all information, even if neutral or adverse, toward one’s own position.

7. Negotiation Strategy

  • Opening proposal: extreme proposals often backfire because it may lead to negotiation being stalled or reaching a very early impasse. Be strategic, not aggressive.
  • Plan a possible concession pattern in advance—the size and timing of each move, and what message it communicates.
  • Identify all terms upfront to avoid adding new, last-minute terms (“Oh, by the way…”).
  • Consider non-monetary terms: timing, payment structure, confidentiality, mutual releases, references, apologies, future dealings.
  • Understand the other party’s perspective—look beyond demands to interests.
  • Handling extreme offers: stay calm, listen to understand rather than to respond. Mediation is about exchanging perspectives.
  • Patience is key—resolving a long-standing dispute takes time, and midday impasses are normal.
  • Plan flexible settlement ranges but avoid setting an unmovable “bottom line.”

8. Preparing the Client Personally

  • The client is the decision-maker; no one will settle without their agreement.
  • Prepare them to hear the other side’s version of events, which may feel unfair or even offensive.
  • Prepare them to discuss the challenges and risks of their case.
  • Discuss the emotional arc: early frustration, midday impasses, late fatigue and pressure.
  • Discuss what closure looks like, and what will remain unresolved, if anything, after any settlement.
  • Cover the practical: timing, location, meals, dress, work and childcare coverage, and phone availability.

9. Documents and Closing

  • Mediation statement submitted; key exhibits, damages model, and lien figures organized.
  • Draft settlement agreement shell in advance, ideally shared with all parties.
  • Authority documentation, release language, and dismissal papers in hand; e-signature capability ready.
  • Reduce any agreement to writing before anyone leaves the session.
  • Terms may include: parties, amount, payment timing, scope of release, dismissal, confidentiality, non-disparagement, lien responsibility, and default remedies.
  • If it does not settle: identify the specific gap and what would close it, keep the mediator available, and debrief the client so the day reads as progress rather than failure.
  • After: calendar every deadline, resolve liens, confirm funds and disbursement, and diary continuing obligations.

Provided for general educational purposes. Not legal advice, and not a substitute for independent judgment about the requirements of a particular matter or jurisdiction.

Download the PDF